Tuesday, 18 January 2011

UK property prices in 2011 - up or down?

So what is it going to be? A return to the bubble years, or a renewed property price crash?

Recent price developments haven't provided much guidance. As the chart illustrates, UK nominal property prices have been treading water for the last nine or so months. They have shown little inclination to go either up or down. Insofar as a trend can be identified, the market appears to be weakening very slightly. Since August, prices are down 0.5 percent. However, that is hardly the sort of decline that will give the nation's rapacious real estate agents sleepless nights.

UK property prices ended last year on a downswing. In December, the Acadametrics national index fell 0.2 percent, compared to the previous month. For the year as a whole, house price inflation was just under 3 percent, and therefore slightly lower than the overall inflation rate. In real terms, house prices fell by the smallest of margins.

Most predictions point to a further round of price declines in 2011. As always, much will depend on the future path of interest rates. If the Bank of England starts to hike the bank rate, the conventional wisdom is that the housing market will weaken.

However, we live in bizarre times where the normal rules no longer apply. In the short run, a rate hike from low current levels won't make much difference to mortgage affordability. Any homeowner with half a brain cell will have already locked in their super low rates when they remortgaged.

Ironically, a rate hike will signal improved economic conditions and an exit from the financial crisis. This will strengthen consumer confidence, which might spillover into the housing market. A rate hike will also improve the functioning of credit markets, which could also increase mortgage approvals.

However, if the Bank delays a rate rise, bad things will happen. It will prolong the pervasive sense of turmoil and weaken consumer confidence. It will also give further credence to the growing expectation of more inflation. If the delay extends into the second half of the year, higher inflation expectations could push long run interest rates upwards, and open up the possibility of a slowdown in GDP.

So how does this inverted story - where a rate hike buttresses consumer expectations and the housing market - fit into the long run assessment that property prices are overvalued? The 2008 house price crash was unusual. Prices fell in nominal terms, which is a rare event in property markets. In previous corrections, the downward adjustment was slow, with rising inflation and incomes doing all the heavy lifting. Homeowners are invariably reluctant to accept nominal price reductions, but seem prepared to absorb an inflation induced adjustment. The future correction is likely to return to a more normal pattern of seller denial, and a slow deterioration of home values as consumer price inflation outstrips house price inflation.

An early rate rate might affect the adjustment path, but it will not affect where prices will be over the long run. Within five or so years, the UK property market will have given up all those gains recorded during the bubble. A delayed rate hike, ironically, might actually speed up the adjustment path, since it will both weaken consumer confidence, and strengthen the growing inflation momentum that is now building up within the UK economy.

For what it is worth, and it is not much, I think the Bank of England will delay the rate hike. Accordingly, house prices will weaken during the first six months of the year. Inflation will pick up, and by mid-year some alarming consumer price index numbers will begin to be printed. At first, there will be denial within the MPC, but eventually there will be a panic rate hike, probably towards the end of the summer.

Once the MPC have come to their senses and begin normalizing the economy, a sense of calm will prevail. Overall, it will be a good thing, but as always, UK home owners will over-react. Towards the end of the year, house prices will temporarily stabilize, and perhaps rise.

So where will house prices be this time next year? It is only a personal view, but I think they will down slightly on where they are today. although I would not rule out the possibility that they are flat, should the MPC raise rates earlier than anticipated.

(Finally, just be clear, this my humble opinion, and it is for entertainment purposes only. If you are in the business of buying property this year, make your own mind up. I make no recommendation to buy, hold or sell.)


Philippines real estate said...

UK property price might go low if minimal buyers only are buying houses.

Anonymous said...


M said...

Up is down, left is right, and a rate increase boosts home values. Still, on the way down, the rate cuts didn't do much to keep prices aloft.

could be......


Mark Wadsworth said...

down down deeper and down!

The Lib-Cons refused to contemplate triggering a swift crash, blaming it all on Labour and then moving on, so what we are looking at is a Japan style scenario where prices drift gently down for decades.

The nominal price inflation we are seeing it largely imported inflation, and wages are going up a lot less than this.

Interestingly, on an inflation-adjusted basis, house prices are back to where they were in 2003 or 2004 (depending on whether you believe Halifax or Nationwide).

Stevie b. said...

Mark "what we are looking at is a Japan style scenario where prices drift gently down for decades."

Nice try - we'll check out your prediction from the grave!

Emily Jones said...


I am Emily Jones and I am a member of some financial communities. I just visited your site ( http://ukhousebubble.blogspot.com/ )and trust me you are doing a good job for your site. I read some of the articles of your site and I really found them worth reading. The quality of your content is excellent. It will help you to earn extra value from Google.

After seeing this, I would like to do something for your site and that is for FREE!!. I love to write financial articles and I would like to contribute something for your site if you'll give me the permission. I can give you an original guest post and I assure you that it will be published only in your site.

Please let me know your thoughts. Waiting for your positive reply. Reach me at: emily.jones025@gmail.com

Thanks and Regards

Emily Jones
Article Marketing Executive

Anonymous said...

Until interest rates rise, it is all smoke and mirrors.

How long that will take is anyones guess.

My current projection is a sterling droop before the year is out; leading to a rise in MLR as a fig leaf.

Marchamont said...

I can see a combination of rising interest rates and falling housing benefit taking the buy to let sector down.

What effect that will have on the rest of the market I really don't know.

Anonymous said...

All bubbles show a brief uptick after the initial decline, I expect caused by the persistence of perceptions -

(Surely it's safe to buy now - after all prices were some way above this present level!)

- but them comes the decline to the real, and much lower bottom. For a commented graphic see:


B. in C.

Anonymous said...

Estate agents rapacious ?? I thought that a description of MPs Lords and energy companies !

chefdave said...

I can't see property prices increasing substantially for quite a long time *in real terms*, there's simply no slack left in the economy for the real estate market to usurp: the BofE shot that bullet when they brought rates down to 0.5%

They'll either gently decline as the country repairs it's balance sheet or the market will go into meltdown due to a sovereign default. 10% yoy capital gains are out of the question.

Anonymous said...

Revolution in 1910, which culminated with the promulgation of the 1917 Constitution and the emergence of the country'sfor instance, with most of Mozart's or Beethoven's sonatas), such a program may prove exhausting to some listeners.
The Only Possible Argument in Support of a Demonstration of the Existence of God. In 1770, at the age of 45, Kant wasMagazine. Estate of Freddie King. I Am the Blues: The Willie Dixon Story. University of Texas Press. No: 25 Freddie